By Dr. Killeen, published on December 07, 2025
This is the closest thing I've found to the original Bite Beauty Lip Mask. It's my absolute favorite and it's cheaper. I've repurchased it like 10 times.
10
out of 10
Brand
Naturium
Price
$13 · 0.5 oz (15g)
Where to Buy
Target ↗Key Ingredients
Shea Butter, Jojoba Oil, Avocado Oil
Pros
+
Lasts all night — still present in the morning
+
Excellent lip moisture and nourishment
+
Best replacement for the original Bite Beauty Agave Lip Mask
+
Incredibly affordable at $13
+
Easy to find at Target
+
Stable glass jar perfect for bedside table
+
Repurchased 10+ times
Cons
–
Thick texture may feel heavy if you prefer lighter lip products
–
Glass jar — not ideal for travel compared to a tube
This is a bottom of the jar review — I used every last bit of this product before giving my honest opinion. And as you can see, I completely cleaned this thing out.
The Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Mask is a thick, creamy overnight lip treatment packed with emollients. It retails for just $13 for 0.5 oz (15g) — a fantastic price for what you get.
It comes in a nice glass component with a plastic lid and a little protective top. The jar is stable and flat, which is perfect for a bedside table — it won't roll off your counter at night. Great design.
This is a thick, creamy lip mask that absorbs nicely but still feels present when you wake up in the morning. Here's what I found:
The formula is full of emollients: shea butter, jojoba oil, and avocado oil. Rich, nourishing ingredients that actually deliver overnight.
Anyone who wakes up with dry, cracked lips. If you loved the original Bite Beauty Agave Lip Mask and have been searching for a replacement since they changed the formula — this is it. And it's cheaper.
I give the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Mask a 10 out of 10. I absolutely love this product. It's my favorite lip treatment, it's inexpensive, easy to find at Target, and I've repurchased it like 10 times. If you're looking for a great nighttime lip treatment, this is definitely the one to try.