Some people shrink up really well, so it's never wrong to just remove and see what happens.
A really thoughtful question came in from a follower considering explant: "What's actually going to happen to my tissue when the implant comes out? Will the skin shrink up enough that I don't need a lift?"
The honest answer is "it depends," but there are very specific anatomic clues we look at to make an educated guess. Let me walk through what implants do to your tissue, what comes back when they're removed, and how I figure out whether a patient is going to need a breast lift after explant or not.
Implants change your chest in a few characteristic ways:
The implant stretches the tissue covering it: skin, breast tissue, and any other layers in between. The thinning is most pronounced directly over the implant and gets progressively less as you move out toward the edges.
So in the middle of your chest, the tissue gets the most stretched and thinned. As you move out toward the sides, the stretching and thinning gets less and less.
The implant takes up space, so anything that was sitting in the central chest gets pushed laterally to make room. Your own breast tissue gets displaced outward.
Immediately after implant removal, the appearance can be surprising for patients who haven't been prepared for it:
This is the acute appearance, not the final result. Over weeks to months, the tissue redistributes, the skin contracts, and things settle. But that initial post-op look can be jarring.
This is where the "will I need a lift" question gets answered. There are specific things I evaluate at consultation that tell me how likely the chest is to shrink back into a reasonable shape on its own.
This is the first thing I look at. I check:
If your nipple is in roughly the right place anatomically, you have a better chance of everything shrinking up. The skin and breast tissue have a good chance of contracting back into a normal shape because the structural landmarks are still where they should be.
If you have smaller implants and your tissue is in the right place, you have a better chance of everything shrinking up without a lift.
This is another group of patients who actually do really well with implant removal:
If your tissue is in the right place, but your implant has bottomed out (the implant has fallen below where it should be while your nipple is still anatomically correct), you often do really well with implant removal and minimal further changes.
These are patients where:
When you remove the implant, the abdominal skin (which was being stretched downward by the bottomed-out implant) usually shrinks up really nicely, and the breast is already about where it's supposed to be.
This is the trickiest scenario, and it's one I want patients to specifically understand because it can be misread.
Sometimes a patient looks at her chest and thinks her nipple is sitting too low, but actually, the nipple isn't low. The implant is high.
Causes of an unusually high implant:
When the implant is sitting high, your nipple sits on the lower curve of the implant when you look down, making it appear that the nipple is low. But measure carefully, and the nipple may not really be low.
For these patients, you may be fine after explant without a lift, other than being a bit hollow up top. Some upper-pole fat grafting may help.
If your nipple is genuinely sitting low (below the inframammary fold, pointing south, well below mid-humerus position), a lift is probably part of your future.
The mechanism is straightforward:
For these patients, a breast lift is worth considering, either at the time of explant or staged afterward.
This is a legitimate strategy for some patients:
The downside is that you may end up needing a second surgery if the tissue doesn't come back as well as we hoped.
For patients who are borderline on needing a lift, I sometimes recommend staged: remove now, see how it heals, then decide on a lift if needed.
For patients who are clearly going to need a lift, doing it at the same operation saves a surgery, and results are typically similar either way. If the capsules need to come out or there isn't much breast tissue, staging is often better.
Sometimes the answer is different on each side.
Here's a patient of mine with severe, painful capsular contractures. The tight scar tissue around her implants was causing really severe pain, and she just wanted them out. She was over it and didn't want anything replaced. Her implants were pretty big, and she wanted to look as good as possible with as little surgery as possible. She also had some asymmetry: her nipples sat in different positions.
When I take implants out of patients with severe contractures, especially with really severe pain, I always take the capsule out. I've found that the tight scar tissue can continue to cause pain even with the implant out, and sometimes it keeps some distortion of the breast, so I can't get the best shape. (More on what adding a capsulectomy means for recovery.)
So she had her implants and capsules removed, and a breast lift on one side only. She now has a lift scar on the right, and just her original crease scar on the left.
That's one option. The other is to match the scars: you do a sham lift on the other side, what I call a "faux-pexy," so both breasts have the same scars and it looks like the same procedure was done on both sides.
Both are decent options. It just depends on what you want as a patient. She wanted as little done as possible, so we only did the side that needed it. She healed really well and did great. (The same one-side-or-both trade-offs come up in implant revisions.)
Here's how I think about this with patients:
| Patient Profile | Likely Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Small implants, nipple in good position | Explant alone, likely no lift needed |
| Larger implants, nipple in good position | Explant + watch healing, possibly stage a lift later |
| Bottomed-out implant, native tissue in place | Explant alone, may need minor revisions |
| Implant sitting too high, nipple "looks" low | Explant, possibly with upper-pole fat grafting; may not need a lift |
| Genuinely low nipple, Grade 2-3 ptosis | Explant with a lift, at the same operation or staged |
This framework is individualized. Your surgeon should be looking at your specific anatomy and walking you through what they see, not giving you a generic answer.
When you're consulting about explant, specific questions to bring up:
A thoughtful surgeon will engage with all of these and not just give you a one-size answer.
When you remove breast implants, your chest initially looks wider, flatter, and sometimes sunken in the middle, especially with larger or higher-profile implants. Over weeks to months, things settle and the tissue redistributes.
Whether you'll need a lift afterward depends on:
If you're unsure, explanting first and watching how things heal is a legitimate strategy. If your nipple is clearly sitting too low, you'll probably need a lift, at the same operation or later.
If only one side needs a lift, you can lift just that side, or match the scars with a faux-pexy on the other side.
This is genuinely a place where anatomy drives the decision, and your surgeon should be able to walk you through exactly what they see and what they predict.
Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.
Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.
Take the first step toward the life you deserve.
Schedule Your ConsultationEvery person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.
Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.
Take the first step toward the life you deserve.
Schedule Your ConsultationRelated Articles

Do You Have to Remove the Capsule When You're Explanting for a Contracture?
May 26, 2026
Dr. Killeen explains when and why she removes the entire capsule during implant removal for capsular contracture, and the real trade-off: adding a capsulectomy raises the risk, mainly bleeding (hematoma), though the overall risk stays low. Plus when leaving some capsule behind is a defensible choice.

What to Do If Your Breast Implants Are Sitting Too High After Surgery
April 28, 2025
Dr. Killeen explains why breast implants often sit too high in the early weeks after augmentation and what to do. The most common causes are a tight or spasming muscle (under the muscle) or tight tissue that has not stretched yet, both usually fixed by tincture of time and sometimes a strap. She covers why massage probably is not doing much, why it is likely not swelling, and the one red flag — an implant that stays high or keeps rising at four to six weeks, which can signal an early capsular contracture.

You're Having an Implant Problem. Do You Replace Them, or Take Them Out for Good?
May 21, 2026
Dr. Killeen walks through the framework for deciding whether to replace your implants or remove them permanently when you're facing a serious implant problem. Plus the case for a third option: removal now, with the option to replace later if you change your mind, and why going back in takes planning: figuring out why the first implant wasn't liked and fixing what it did to the pocket.