Implants or a DIEP Flap? How to Choose Your Breast Reconstruction

By Dr. Kelly Killeen, MD FACS · Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon · Published November 29, 2024 · Updated November 21, 2026

It doesn't matter what your friend did. It doesn't matter what the person in your support group did. What matters is what you want for your body and what works well with your anatomy.

Implants or a DIEP Flap?

I love this question from a commenter: why do people choose implants or a DIEP flap when they're a candidate for both? Especially in the prophylactic mastectomy population, like patients with a BRCA gene mutation.

The Two Worlds of Breast Reconstruction

In breast reconstruction, there are two big worlds:

  • The implant world. That's most of what I do. We use an implant, a prosthetic device, to recreate the breast after a mastectomy. (Here's how direct-to-implant reconstruction works.)
  • The autologous world. This is the "rob Peter to pay Paul" world: you take a piece of you from somewhere else, move it to the chest, and make a breast out of it.

A DIEP flap is exactly that. We take tissue from the lower abdomen and move it up to the chest, sewing tiny blood vessels together so it can live and thrive in its new home.

All of these are great methods of reconstruction. The key, as a patient, is figuring out what risks you're willing to take and what benefits you really want from your procedure.

Implant-Based Reconstruction: Pros and Cons

Upsides:

  • It looks like an implant, and a lot of women love the look of breast implants.
  • It's a much shorter surgery with an easier recovery.

Downsides:

  • You now have a prosthetic device that you have to take care of, with the potential complications that come with it.

Implant reconstruction comes with its own decisions too, like over vs. under the muscle and saving the nipple.

DIEP Flap Reconstruction: Pros and Cons

Upsides:

  • You're using your own tissue, so there's no prosthetic device.

Downsides:

  • It's a much bigger surgery up front.
  • You're operating on an area of the body that isn't affected, so you could have complications and new scars somewhere that didn't need surgery to solve a problem in your chest.

Most Reconstructions in the US Use Implants

In the United States, roughly 20% of breast reconstructions are autologous, which means implant-based reconstruction is much more common.

That's really for the reasons above. When patients are dealing with a reconstruction, they often want something that will get them healed quicker, and that doesn't operate somewhere outside the problem, so to speak. They don't want a brand-new scar in another area of the body, or the potential complications there.

What Female Plastic Surgeons Would Choose

A survey published in 2009 asked every board-certified female plastic surgeon in the US and Canada: if you needed breast reconstruction, what would you choose? You're asking the experts who do these procedures what they would have done if it were them.

The results looked a lot like what women in the US actually choose:

  • 66% would have an implant-based reconstruction
  • 25% would have an autologous reconstruction
  • 9% wouldn't have reconstruction

When asked why, the surgeons who chose implants most often pointed to the less invasive surgery and shorter recovery. The ones who chose autologous reconstruction most often said they thought the aesthetic outcome was better.

We female plastic surgeons, we're just like you.

Why Prophylactic Patients Often Choose Implants

I'm not sure of the exact numbers for prophylactic patients on their own, separate from reconstruction patients in general. But prophylactic patients are often younger, and many of them haven't had children yet. They often don't want to do too much surgery to alter their bodies. And many haven't developed that "mom belly," which is the tissue a DIEP flap uses. (It's also why I get asked whether to skip a tummy tuck in case you need a DIEP flap later.)

All of that probably rolls into why you see less autologous reconstruction in that population, too. If you're a BRCA carrier just starting to think this through, here's what to know about BRCA testing.

It Only Matters What's Right for You

It doesn't matter what your friend did. It doesn't matter what the person in your support group did. What matters is what you want for your body, and what works well with your anatomy.

The Bottom Line

  • There are two worlds of reconstruction: implants, and your own tissue, like a DIEP flap.
  • Implants: a shorter surgery, an easier recovery, and a look many women love, but a device to take care of, with its own potential complications.
  • DIEP flap: your own tissue and no device, but a much bigger surgery, with scars and possible complications in an area that wasn't affected.
  • About 20% of US reconstructions are autologous, and in a 2009 survey, two-thirds of female plastic surgeons said they'd choose implants for themselves.
  • Prophylactic patients are often younger, often haven't had kids, and often want less surgery, which likely pushes them toward implants.
  • The right choice is the one that fits your goals and your anatomy, not anyone else's.

Your Journey to Renewed Confidence

Journey to Renewed Confidence

Transform Your Life

Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.

Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.

Take the first step toward the life you deserve.

Schedule Your Consultation
Journey to Renewed Confidence

Transform Your Life

Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.

Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.

Take the first step toward the life you deserve.

Schedule Your Consultation

Related Articles

Should You Skip a Tummy Tuck in Case You Need a DIEP Flap Later?

Should You Skip a Tummy Tuck in Case You Need a DIEP Flap Later?

January 6, 2026

Dr. Killeen pushes back on the advice to avoid tummy tucks or liposuction in case of future breast reconstruction — and explains why most women will never need a DIEP flap.

Can You Reconstruct a Breast With Only Fat Grafting After a Mastectomy?

Can You Reconstruct a Breast With Only Fat Grafting After a Mastectomy?

June 5, 2026

Dr. Killeen explains the reality of fat-grafting-only breast reconstruction after mastectomy: why it takes many rounds of surgery (one patient needed six), the skin retraction problem, the imaging complications that matter for cancer survivors, and why a flap is worth asking about if you want to use your own tissue.

Nipple Reconstruction Options After Mastectomy

Nipple Reconstruction Options After Mastectomy

January 20, 2026

Dr. Killeen explains the options for nipple reconstruction after breast cancer surgery — from 3D tattooing and flap procedures to silicone prosthetics.

Dr. Kelly Killeen Logo

436 N. Bedford Dr., Suite 103

Beverly Hills, CA 90210

(323) 800-8588

Quick Links

Breast Procedures

© 2026 Dr. Kelly Killeen. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

|

Terms & Conditions