I always recommend removing the implant shell. You have a damaged foreign object and I just do not love that for any patient. I see a lot of issues with the shell folding, where the patient gets a weird little point that distorts the shape of their chest, and if they are very thin it can actually erode through the skin.
If your saline implant has deflated, either because you had it drained or because it simply broke, you're left with an empty shell sitting in the pocket. So the question comes up: do you actually have to take it out?
You can do anything you want. Nobody is going to force you into surgery. But I always recommend removing the implant shell, and here's my reasoning.
The simplest version of my objection:
You have a damaged foreign object in your body, and I just don't love that for any patient.
An intact implant is a medical device doing a job. A collapsed shell isn't doing anything, it's just material left behind. If I can remove it for you, I'd like to.
Any foreign body carries potential for infection and problems. That's true of implants generally, and it doesn't stop being true once the implant has failed.
I want to be measured here: infection is not horribly common in this situation. I'm not trying to frighten anyone. But it's a non-zero risk you're carrying for no benefit, since the deflated shell isn't providing shape or volume anymore. (For context on what infections look like when they do happen, see how we diagnose and treat implant infections.)
This is the problem I actually see most often, and it's the one patients don't anticipate.
An empty shell doesn't lie flat. It folds. That's true even if the implant is only partially deflated. And when it folds, patients get a weird little point or area that distorts the shape of the chest.
It's not subtle to the person living with it. You can often feel a firm edge or corner where the collapsed material has bunched up, and it can be visible depending on your tissue.
This is the one that pushes it from "recommended" to "please do this."
If you're very thin, a folded shell can actually erode through the skin. The shell creates a firm point, that point presses outward against tissue with little padding over it, and over time it can work its way through.
That turns a simple elective removal into a wound problem with an exposed implant, which is a substantially harder situation to manage than just taking the shell out in the first place.
A lot of saline augmentations are under the muscle. When the pectoralis muscle has been elevated and stretched over an implant for years and years, leaving a deflated implant sitting under it doesn't help. The muscle tends to move even more strangely than it did with a working implant in place, so you get weird muscle movement.
That's why I'm a big fan of removing the implant and repairing the muscle, especially for an under-the-muscle patient. (Here's why and how I repair the muscle during implant removal.)
If you've had a saline deflation, talk to your surgeon about taking the shell out, and about whether you want to replace the implant or remove them permanently while you're at it. It's usually a straightforward operation, and it's a lot easier to do on your schedule than after a complication forces the issue.
Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.
Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.
Take the first step toward the life you deserve.
Schedule Your ConsultationEvery person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change. They're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.
Dr. Killeen and her team support you every step of the way, from your first consultation through recovery.
Take the first step toward the life you deserve.
Schedule Your ConsultationRelated Articles

Ruptured Silicone Implant: Should You Remove the Capsule or Leave It Behind?
May 30, 2025
Dr. Killeen explains why she removes the capsule when a silicone implant has ruptured — even when it looks soft and normal — because the silicone-contaminated capsule can drive a capsular contracture later. With a real patient example and the honest caveat that surgeons disagree.

Very Little Tissue and Considering a Breast Augmentation: Under or Over the Muscle?
June 15, 2026
Dr. Killeen breaks down the under-vs-over-the-muscle decision for thin breast augmentation patients — the traditional pinch test, why modern cohesive implants and fat grafting have changed the old rules, and the overlooked trade-off: thin patients see the implant more under the muscle, but they also see the muscle move more.

How to Hide Implant Edges If You're Thin
November 25, 2025
Dr. Killeen explains options for thin patients concerned about visible implant edges — from fat grafting and fat substitutes to implant selection and placement strategies.