What I Look For When Hiring a Nurse Practitioner

By Dr. Kelly Killeen, MD FACS · Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon · Published April 4, 2025

I love working with people who really think about problems before they come to me. When a patient has an issue, they have already thought about what they think it is and what the solution is, even if it is a new problem. I like an active mind and people who are always thinking three steps ahead.

What I Look For When Hiring a Nurse Practitioner

I get asked this a lot, so let's talk about what I actually look for when hiring a nurse practitioner for my plastic surgery team.

I wish I could give you an exact scientific formula. I can't, a lot of it is getting a feel for someone. But there are specific things I'm looking for every time, and here they are.

1. A Background With Real Autonomy

The first thing I look for is a history of working in an area with more autonomy.

This matters especially for a new grad who hasn't yet worked as a nurse practitioner. In that case, I look at their experience as a nurse, and specifically whether they worked somewhere they had to function independently. The settings that stand out:

  • Emergency department
  • Labor and delivery
  • ICU
  • Surgery

I find that nurses with that kind of experience tend to make the best nurse practitioners for my field. They've already had to make calls under pressure without someone standing over them, and that translates directly.

2. Genuine Curiosity

This one is more of a je ne sais quoi, but I can usually tell within an interview whether someone is curious.

I love people who are open, curious, and eager to learn. I want someone who seems genuinely excited about the subject matter, even when it's completely new to them. Plastic surgery has a steep learning curve, and enthusiasm for the material beats existing knowledge every time.

3. A Personality That Can Hold Its Own

The next thing is overall personality and how well someone meshes with me specifically.

I'll be blunt about this: timid personalities don't do well in this field. I like people who are:

  • Strong
  • Assertive
  • Comfortable having discussions with me right off the bat

If you can't push back on me in an interview, it's going to be hard to push back on me when it matters, and in medicine, that matters. I want someone who will say "I think we should look at this again."

4. Problem Solving vs. Information Gathering

This is the big one, and it's the thing I evaluate during the trial period. When I hire someone, we usually have a several-month trial period, which is pretty standard for this kind of role.

What I'm watching for is the difference between problem solving and information gathering.

I love working with people who really think about a problem before they bring it to me.

Here's the distinction in practice. When a patient has an issue, the person I want has already thought through what they believe it is and what they think the solution is before they walk into my office, even when it's a brand-new problem. They may be wrong, that's fine. But they've engaged with it.

The alternative is someone who simply gathers information and hands it to me to solve. And I can always tell which one I'm getting by the way information arrives.

I want an active mind, someone always thinking three steps ahead. That way they're a genuine part of the team, and together we take better care of the patient. That collaborative capability is a big part of how a practice actually manages complications well.

5. Good Vibes, Genuinely

The last thing is simple: I like good vibes. I like positive people.

We are together all the time. And more importantly, we are our patients' biggest cheerleaders when they're going through something hard. A lot of what we do involves people at vulnerable moments, cancer diagnoses, difficult recoveries, complications.

I want a sunny personality to complement mine, so that our patients have a genuinely great experience and we can hype them up during the hard stuff. That isn't a soft consideration. For the patient, it's a real part of the care.

The Bottom Line

What I look for in a nurse practitioner:

  1. Autonomous background, ED, L&D, ICU, or surgery experience
  2. Curiosity, open and excited to learn, even about unfamiliar material
  3. A strong, assertive personality that can hold a discussion with me
  4. Problem solving over information gathering, thinking three steps ahead
  5. Good vibes, because we're together constantly and our patients need cheerleaders

None of that is a formula, and I still go on feel more than I'd like to admit. But if you're a nurse hoping to move into plastic surgery, those are the things that make me lean forward in an interview.

Your Journey to Renewed Confidence

Journey to Renewed Confidence

Transform Your Life

Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change—they're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.

Dr. Killeen's expertise and compassionate approach ensure that your journey is supported every step of the way, from initial consultation through complete recovery.

Take the first step toward the life you deserve.

Schedule Your Consultation
Journey to Renewed Confidence

Transform Your Life

Every person deserves to feel comfortable and confident in their own body. Our procedures aren't just about physical change—they're about reclaiming your life, your comfort, and your self-assurance.

Dr. Killeen's expertise and compassionate approach ensure that your journey is supported every step of the way, from initial consultation through complete recovery.

Take the first step toward the life you deserve.

Schedule Your Consultation
Dr. Kelly Killeen Logo

436 N. Bedford Dr., Suite 103

Beverly Hills, CA 90210

(323) 800-8588

Quick Links

Breast Procedures

© 2026 Dr. Kelly Killeen. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

|

Terms & Conditions